zenpundit.com » Uncategorized

Archive for the ‘Uncategorized’ Category

Apocalyptic arrives, but not yet the Coming One

Tuesday, September 16th, 2014

[ by Charles Cameron -- on the intersecting logics of IS, current and classical Islamic eschatology, and violent millennial movements in general ]

 Al Malhamah al Kubra, the great end times battle, image from Dabiq

Al Malhamah al Kubra, the great end times battle


Ella Lipin, research associate for Middle East studies for the Council on Foreign Relations, blogged on the apocalyptic side of the “caliphate” a few days back under the title Understanding ISIS’s Apocalyptic Appeal:

To the outside world, this period of atrocities perpetrated by ISIS, such as the beheading of two American journalists, may be another defining moment in shaping the Middle East. But for many people in the region, ISIS’s message resounds and its arrival marks the end of days and the fulfillment of divine prophecy. To understand ISIS’s appeal and ultimately how to defeat it, the United States must recognize how the organization situates itself within Islamic apocalyptic tradition.

That’s good, that’s fine.


To back up a bit, Martin Dempsey said of IS almost a month ago:

This is an organisation that has an apocalyptic, end-of-days strategic vision which will eventually have to be defeated.

I noted this with approval, and lamented the lack of earlier awareness of this point in my post The curious case of the unheard word “apocalyptic”.


And today, Terrence McCoy of the Washington Post quoted Ms Lipin in a piece about Dabiq magazine titled The apocalyptic magazine the Islamic State uses to recruit and radicalize foreigners:

This is not the beginning, the magazine says. It is the end. It is the culmination of a centuries-long war that has burned and simmered but never been extinguished — that will soon grow to consume everything. It is the apocalypse. And it is coming.

This is the chilling vision set out in the Islamic State magazine called “Dabiq,” published in several European languages including English.

Again, that’s good to see.


But what exactly are the implications?

I’ve posted my own detailed analysis of a mere 10 pages of Dabiq, focusing explicitly on implications regarding the Saved Sect and the Victorious Group, and the entire logical edifice IS has constructed to take us from the Dabiq hadith via the notion of hirah to the recruitment of a global force of jihadists, in Dabiq issue 3 part 1- Hijrah. Tim Furnish has blogged about this, as has J-P Filiu. Their work is of crucial importance, along with that of David Cook. And the posts I’ve linked here are far from all these scholars have written — each has been covering specifically Islamic apocalyptic for years.


But that’s the IS logic, and there are other logics that need to be understood.

One is the Islamic logic that views IS as Kharijites, “breakaways” and heretics who in an excess of religious fervor have broken away from the very religion they profess to follow. That’s a topic that should be addressed from within Islam, IMO. For now, here’s a link to a short video from a Manchester (UK) Salafist sheikh, who views both IS and JN as Kharijite. I’ll report here if I see this line of argument particularly well presented.

In strictly poetic terms, there’s Shadab Zeest Hashmi‘s Shade, posted in 3QuarksDaily — if you still have a heart for beauty in these grim times:

Allahu Akbar or God is Great, the anthem stolen by the wicked terrorist, whose attack is aimed at life, what holds life together for me— the zikr: Allahu Akbar, God is Greater, greater than prayer, greater than the spectacularly leaping science, the elegance of logic, the morality police, the lust of the spirit or the intellect, greater than the molten heart of a mother, a day laborer’s fatigue, greater than the beauty of discipline, the disciple of beauty, the ecstasy of disarray, greater than terra firma or the firmament, greater than sorrow.

If you still have a mind for poetry.


But there’s at least one other logic that needs to be understood — because it shows what the modifier “apocalyptic” can do to an already violent movement. It’s the logic explored by scholars like Jeffrey Kaplan, Michael Barkun, Catherine Wessinger, Michael Barkun, Richard Landes, Jean Rosenfeld, and John R Hall.

That’ll require a whole new post. But it’s the horse that pulls the cart of millennial and messianic / mahdist movements — and maybe we should understand the horse before the cart?


Rumors of Wars

Tuesday, September 16th, 2014

[ by Charles Cameron -- there are times when rumors can make or break a war ]

I see these three tweets as the tip of a much larger iceberg:

Rumors of wars are a potential and potent accelerant of wars.


Appreciation to the NYT, nicely observed by Amil Khan, h/t to Abu Muqawama.



Tuesday, September 16th, 2014

[ by Charles Cameron -- of the Camerons of Erracht ]

2Tim4 602


With all the current talk of Scottish Independence, and given my own myopic focus on matters scriptural and theological, I thought it might be apposite to post a few verses from the New Testament in the braid tongue of my forefathers before me.

Happening across the logo at the top of this post while googling, I thought I’d bring you a taste of Chaptir Fowr of Second Timothy;

I chairge ye, i’ the presence o’God, and Christ Jesus wha is to judge the leevin and the deid, and by his shinin-forth and kingdom,

Gie oot the word! Press ye in season and oot o’ season; convince, rebute, entreat, wi’ a lang-tholin and doctrine.

For thar wull be a time whan halesome teachin they winna thole : but, conform to their ain desires, and haein a yeuck i’ their lugs, wull gaither-up teachers to theirsels;

And wull turn awa frae hearin the truth, and turn agley to glaikit tales.

But be ye watchfu’ in a’ things, thole afflictions, do the wark o’ an evangelist, fulfil yere service.

For I am bein offer’t, and the time o’ my settin-free is at haun.

The gude-fecht hae I fouchten, the race hae I run, the faith hae I keepit!

From The New Testament in Braid Scots, with a glossary of Scottish terms rendered by Rev. William Wye Smith. My copy is of the 1924 printing.


I’m not qualified to vote, which is probably a good thing — but I’ll certainly be interested to see what my clanfolk and kinfolk decide this Thursday…


Another Sunday Surprise: Gould and Turner

Sunday, September 14th, 2014

[ by Charles Cameron -- this one's for the creative cognition folks out there in Zenland ]

Damn’d hard to read, I know, but worth it if you care about artistic creation & performance:

SPEC gould turner

The top quote is Glenn Gould, speaking in the documentary Glenn Gould, Hereafter, the second from the erudite and delightful poet, distinguished professor and friend, Frederick Turner‘s blog.


James Risen on a roll

Sunday, September 14th, 2014

[ by Charles Cameron -- the Dostum is in the details ]

It began like this:

– and Risen was on a roll… He went on to say:

Talk about a turnaround — in 2009, Obama promised to investigate my story about Dostom and the Bush Administration. Dostom’s forces were accused of killing thousands of Taliban POWs by suffocating them in large cargo containers. Dostom has denied it.

Ashraf Ghani, likely Afghanistan’s next president, used to call Dostum a “known killer.” Now he calls him his running mate. So as Iraq falls apart because of sectarian government installed by the US, the US is installing a govt. in Afghan. with a VP widely considered a war criminal by Pashtuns. Remember this whenever likely Afghan VP Dostum makes his first official visit to the US

So in Afghanistan and Iraq, we have failed to learn a basic lesson– counter-terrorism operations can’t be the end all and be all. They are only supposed to provide time and space for political settlements and reconciliation. But we have forgotten that part. We have focused on short-term tactical solutins for deep-seated problems. In Iraq, we can bomb ISIS, but dealing with the central fact: our 2003 invasion overturned the political sociology of Iraq.

What is Secretary of State John Kerry going to say when he greets (likely) Afghan VP Dostum? “Hey, Dostum, how are you treating prisoners?”

There was much more, on a youthful tangent — the above is the part I wanted to bring you.


Please forgive the typo: you know what he means.


Switch to our mobile site