CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I

Three years back, Glenn Beck interviewed this same Joel Rosenberg, who writes about end-times Christianity and Islam and the need to support Israel from an end-times perspective — and the pair of them put out a sadly and dangerously muddled message. This excerpt from the transcript is worth noting for the significance it attributes to Mahdist eschatology and thus insinuates into the minds of millions of Americans:

BECK: OK. So, the Ayatollah Khomeini and the revolution of ‘79, he said these 12ers are too crazy for even him. What happened, because — is Ahmadinejad the only one? Are there a lot of them? It’s my understanding that the government now is full of these people. Is that true?

ROSENBERG: That’s right. Well, the Ayatollah Khamenei, the current supreme leader, was a disciple of the Ayatollah Khomeini.

BECK: OK.

ROSENBERG: Apparently, it’s turned out that he has been a secret closet 12er, because he clearly believes the same thing as Ahmadinejad.

Here’s what’s wrong: both Beck and Rosenberg seem to have confused “Twelvers” (the Ithna’ashariyya who make up about 85% of all Shi’a, though there are important smaller sects such as the Ismai’li) with a small and secretive faction within the Iranian Shi’a, almost certainly the Hojjatieh.

Beck says:

I want to talk to you about something that nobody seems to ever notice when they talk about Iran. When we’re talking about Iran, we’re talking about people, the leaders, that are called, they’re called “Twelvers” — they believe in the Twelfth Imam, the Mahdi. This is one spooky dude. Twelvers are so dangerous that the Ayatollah Khomeini at one point banned them, said we’ve gotta kill ’em all because they’re too crazy — the Ayatollah Khomeini said that.

It makes absolutely no sense to say that the Ayatollah Khomeini condemned the Twelvers — he was their leader in Iran — but he did oppose the (arguably extremist) Hojjatieh, which was basically a secret society — and that is almost certainly the group that Beck was thinking of.

But then Joel Rosenberg seems to get swept up in Beck’s confused and confusing rhetoric, and goes on to call the Ayatollah Khamenei “a secret, closet Twelver” — a phrase he also uses in his 2010 book, The Twelfth Imam (pp. 178, 259), and which is particularly inept since Rosenberg knows enough to have discussed the Hojjatieh in his book Inside The Revolution (copyright 2009, 2011), in which he writes (pp. 161-62):

During this same period, it appears Ahmadinejad was also involved in a shadowy Islamic society known as the Hojatieh, whose leaders taught that the Twelfth Imam was coming soon and whose members believed they were required to take spiritual (but not political) actions to hasten his coming. … the movement discouraged people from being fully devoted to creating an Islamic state, preferring instead to wait for it to come from the sky. In 1983, therefore, Khomeini actually banned the Hojatieh, and Ahmadinejad seems to have subsumed his sympathies for the group to protect his opportunities for career advancement.

**

I am happy to report that Joel Richardson, the other Joel currently writing about Islamic apocalyptic from a Christian end-times perspective, corrects Beck and Rosenberg on this point in his blog, Joel’s Trumpet:

Beck needs to have me on sometime. He gets a lot of his info wrong. Ayatollah Khomeini never banned “Twelvers”, as he himself was one. He banned the Hojjatieh of which Ahmadinejad is arguably a member of and which Mesbah Yazdi below is as well.

Beck’s the one Joel Richardson was addressing, but his critique applies equally to both Beck and Rosenberg. But this post is getting overlong, so I’ll continue with background from a scholar friend in a continuation of this post…

Page 2 of 2 | Previous page

  1. This Week’s Watcher’s Council Nominations – March Madness Edition » Virginia Right!:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  2. Trevor Loudon's New Zeal Blog » This Week’s Watcher’s Council Nominations – March Madness Edition:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  3. This Week’s Watcher’s Council Nominations – March Madness Edition | askmarion:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  4. This Week’s Watcher’s Council Nominations – March Madness Edition | therightplanet.com:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  5. This Week’s Watcher’s Council Nominations | therightplanet.com:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  6. GayPatriot » Watcher of Weasels — Nominations March 21 2013:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt Isubmitted by The Glittering […]

  7. Trevor Loudon's New Zeal Blog » The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watcher’s Council Results – 03/22/13:

    […] place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  8. The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watcher’s Council Results » Virginia Right!:

    […] place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit -CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  9. The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watcher’s Council Results – 03/22/13 | therightplanet.com:

    […] place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  10. The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watcher’s Council Results | askmarion:

    […] place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I submitted by The Glittering […]

  11. WoW Weekly Offerings |:

    […] Pundit – CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt Isubmitted by The Glittering […]

  12. Bookworm Room » Watcher of Weasels has good stuff that you’ll want to know about:

    […] place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit -CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I    submitted by The Glittering […]

  13. Take Time to Sniff the Roses |:

    […] place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit -CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I    submitted by The Glittering […]

  14. Watcher of Weasels » The Council Has Spoken!! This Week’s Watcher’s Council Results:

    […]   submitted by The Political Commentator Fifth place with 1 vote – Zen Pundit -CENTCOM, Rosenberg and Islamic eschatology, pt I    submitted by The Glittering Eye Sixth place *t* with 2/3 votes – Selwyn Duke/Canada […]