zenpundit.com » 2015 » November

Archive for November, 2015

Poetry is dead vs the death penalty for poetry?

Monday, November 30th, 2015

[ by Charles Cameron — current affairs, target practice, and incarnation ]
.

Ah.

Palestinian poet and painter Ahraf Fayadh is currently under a death sentence in Saudi Arabia.

It appears important to recognize the full human significance of one’s target

**

Flaubert apparently pronounced poetry dead in his posthumous opus, Bouvard et Pécuchet, 1881, and even Newsweek had noted the fact — “filed under: News” — by 2003. Neither Flaubert nor Newsweek, however, was reckoning on the long-standing Arab enthusiasm for poetry, nicely illustrated to this day by the seriousness with which the authorities treat their poets.

**

Oh..

and while we’re on the subject of targeting..

it may also be wise to recognize the full divine significance of one’s target.

Early notes on McCants’ The ISIS Apocalypse

Sunday, November 29th, 2015

[ by Charles Cameron — a couple of grace-notes while I’m working on my review of Will McCants‘ book, The ISIS Apocalypse ]
.

One:

My first note concerns the elegant way in which McCants‘ view of the changing state of IS eschatology as it has developed in practice conforms to Max Weber‘s theory of the routinization of charisma:

SPEC DQ Weber McCants

Toth, Toward a Theory of the Routinizationnof Charisma
McCants, p 147

**

Two:

There are four sentences that fall in series in Will McCants’s Conclusion — three of a kind followed by one with a different quality to it. Each one ends a section, and the last ends the Conclusion as a whole:

  • This is not Bin Laden’s apocalypse.
  • This is not Bin Laden’s insurgency.
  • This is not Bin Laden’s caliphate.
  • This may not be Bin Laden’s jihad, but it’s a formula future jihadists will find hard to resist.
  • The relevant pages respectively are pp. 147, 151, 153, and 159.

    Tim Furnish update, new book just out

    Saturday, November 28th, 2015

    [ by Charles Cameron — this just out from Tim Furnish, author of Holiest Wars: Islamic Mahdis, Their Jihads, and Osama bin Laden ]
    .

    I’m looking forward to reviewing this, from my friend and our blog-friend Tim Furnish:

    A second volume of Tim’s recent writings should be out shortly.

    On form and beauty

    Saturday, November 28th, 2015

    [ by Charles Cameron — capable photographers capture “form” in their viewfinders, not just “content” ]
    .

    A toothy sea
    A toothy sea

    **

    I have just been browsing someone’s choice of the “100 best photographs ever taken without photoshop”, and was struck by the ways in which form in general, and contrasts in juxtaposition more specifically — two of my recurring interests, form and the DoubleQuotes respectively — kept cropping up. I’ll get to them, and offer some stepped-down images from the series —

    but first, take a look at the whole series as posted at The 100 best photographs ever taken without photoshop. Even the reduction to 60% of published size necessitated by the ZP column width loses much of the beauty — and imagine how they’d be as actual framed prints, in their original full sizes!

    Someone’s choices? Yes, and by no means necessarily the best choices — this selection no doubt answers to a selection bias in the individual who put the series together — so the patterns I’m seeing here may belong either to that individual, or to the general human delight in contrasts, parallelisms and oppositions.

    **

    Earth and Sky, Heaven and Earth:

    Waterspout on Lake Victoria, Uganda
    Waterspout on Lake Victoria, Uganda

    Fickle moods
    Fickle moods

    Volcanic eruption in IcelandVolcanic eruption in Iceland

    **

    The seasons: time as change

    An autumn forest. 50 percent Downloaded
    An autumn forest. 50 percent Downloaded

    Autumn and winter meet in Colorado, USA
    Autumn and winter meet in Colorado, USA

    Autumn and winter meet in Miklukhin, Rostov region, Russia
    Autumn and winter meet in Miklukhin, Rostov region, Russia

    **

    Human impact observed:

    Two worlds divided, New York, USA
    Two worlds divided, New York, USA

    Celebrating the 100th anniversary of the birth of Kim Il-sung, North Korea’s founder
    Celebrating the 100th anniversary of the birth of Kim Il-sung, North Korea’s founder

    An Italian beach
    An Italian beach

    **

    On reflection, sheer, simple symmetries:

    The aftermath of a flood in Ljubljana, Slovenia
    The aftermath of a flood in Ljubljana, Slovenia

    An eagle soaring over a lake in Canada
    An eagle soaring over a lake in Canada

    **

    And that’s only a fraction of what the whole series of a hundred photos offers us. Each of these, I’d submit, is what I’d term a DoubleQuote in the Wild.

    One final shot, color against grey — perhaps the loveliest of all:

    A temple covered in ash from the Ontake volcanic eruption, Japan
    A temple covered in ash from the Ontake volcanic eruption, Japan

    So much humanity, so much pathos there.

    **

    Brilliant minds in both the arts and sciences focus as much on form as on content — on patterns, repetitions, symmetries for their own sakes, as much as on the particulars of the fields they study and in which they find them. At heart, this is a matter of aesthetic cognition.

    We would do well to cultivate this kind of double vision — the awareness of form as well as content — across the board, from education and the arts to the sciences and strategy.

    The moment we become polarized, however, in terms of a political or other form of partisanship, content becomes all we see (and agree or disagree with), and form effectively evaporates. In terms of the images above, we see earth or sky, summer or autumn, town or country — left or right — but not — but no longer — the whole.

    Recommended Reading, Thanksgiving Weekend Edition

    Saturday, November 28th, 2015

    [by Mark Safranski, a.k.a. “zen“]

    A special feast of recent posts…..

    T. Greer at Scholar’s Stage – Vox Will Never Understand Islam… Or Any Religion, Really  and Editorial vs. Coffee House Blogging

    The critique was written by a friend of mine in a private forum. I repost it here with his permission. He touches on a few themes that will be familiar to readers of the Stage: the banality of Washington opinion writers, forever stitching new headlines into tired narratives; the limits liberal education in the 21st century, far better at teaching platitudes than exploring the depths of the human condition; and the inability of secular elites to understand religions and the religious masses who earnestly believe in them. He starts his attack with Fischer’s statement, “people get out of [religions] what they bring into them.” The bolded emphasis is my own: 

    …If you are not particularly religious, and furthermore do not know much at all about religion — except the assumptions you bring to the topic from your inadequate formal and experiential educations — then you will write, without embarrassment, things like, “religions are big and diverse, and people get out of them what they bring into them.”

    Let me amend that, and not in favor of the writer: it is not even necessary to know about religion as such to know this is false — it is simply necessary to know about literature, and not to any real depth. This is the sort of thing that reasonably educated people ought not to say and still less believe, as it is so evidently wrong — but it is also the sort of thing that wide swaths of our media establishment, of course chief among them the powerholder-stenographers at Vox, credulously declare. [….]

    Global Guerrillas –Supersoldiers and Autonomous Weapons

    Fast forward 20 years (about the age of the WWW).  An aging, schlerotic EU has become the destination for over a hundred million refugees and migrants fleeing the densely populated killing fields of Africa and SW Asia.  

    The rapidity of influx has led the EU to take extreme measures.   Tens of millions of these migrants/refugees are roughly housed in relocation camps all across Europe.  

    Violence within these camps has risen steadily, leading to an EU-wide Islamic insurgency.

    The soldiers sent to counter this insurgency are outfitted with autonomous weapons.  These weapons combine deep learning (making them very smart) and cloud robotics (allowing the military to rapidly share advances in training and technique) to provide these soldiers with capabilities far beyond what we’ve seen in previous wars.    

    Here’s an idealized example so you can get the idea.  A human/robot team advances down a street in an urban environment.  [….]

    Adam Elkus – ISIS, the Clash of Civilizations and the Problem of Apologetics 

    ….How did this happen? How did we go from generalized agreement during the Bush administration that the enemy is only the terrorists themselves to calls for a Muslim database? Marc Lynch has a piece up at Monkey Cage in which he talks about the eternal recurrence of “clash of civilizations” narratives and the increasingly disturbing rise of anti-Islam rhetoric among US politicians and the media. Lynch supplies a lot of of valid reasons for why this is the case, who is responsible, and how such filth has been legitimized. However, one important reason is missing?—?the way in which analysts have structurally obsfucated many of the important issues at play regarding the connection between religion and ISIS (and others’ political violence). In attempting to prevent bigots from validating a “clash of civilizations” narrative, analysts have paradoxically helped bring it about.

    As a prelude, let’s begin with the phrase “clash of civilizations.” It’s often axiomatic among researchers that Samuel Huntington, the man who coined the term, is guilty of “profound racism.” But very few have ever read the book or the original articles in detail. Huntington had argued publically that civilizations as categories ought to be respected, and that a lack of attention and respect to their civilizational perogatives and differences would lead to unnecessary strife. Huntington argued that the only way coexistence was would be if the West could understand the rest despite grave differences. Huntington’s cultural relativism is not exactly novel; it appears in social psychology and has been a constant in anthropology and sociology to some degree since the founding of those disciplines. It has also found some parallel in area studies and regional international relations.

    Martin van Creveld – The Clash of Civilizations and the End of History*

    Feral Jundi – Russia: So Where Are Russian PMSC’s Working In The World? and Yemen: UAE Deploys It’s Colombian Mercenaries To Yemen

    Peter Turchin – Ultrasociety: How 10,000 Years of War Made Humans the Greatest Cooperators on Earth

    The Bridge – #Reviewing The Future of Land Warfare:

    Angry Staff Officer – History the Overlooked Military Discipline

    OLD AMIGOS…..

    The Glittering Eye – Assumptions About the Turkey-Russia Incident

    Dr. Chet Richards at the Lean Kanban Conference –  the full length interview.

    Dr. Thomas P.M. Barnett has returned to blogging

    Shlok Vaidya – On Human Evolution, Personality Disorders and the Environment

    ONLINE ZINES & JOURNALS…..

    War on the Rocks – How Many Fighters Does the Islamic State Really Have?

    Small Wars Journal –The Starfish Caliphate: How ISIL Exploits the Power of a Decentralized Organization

    Infinity Journal – D – All of The Above: Connecting 21st Century Naval Doctrine to Strategy

    Cicero – Why Are the Religions of the West so Violent?

    Aeon – Head to Head

    That’s it!


    Switch to our mobile site